Whole Pies

Build Your Own Pie

$16.25

Stars with our hand tossed crust, original or Spicy sauce, and shredded mozzarella cheese. Then you choose what to add to make it your own! Starts at $16.25, $1.99 for additional toppings.

Pizza of the Month

$23.25

Our October Pizza of the Month is the Buckin' Bronco! Sausage, beef, bacon, onions, bbq sauce, tomatoes, pickle chips,and colby cheese

The PBR (Pickle, Bacon, Ranch)

$21.75

A BEST SELLER has been added to the menu! Pickle, bacon, ranch, cream cheese, and dill seasoning.

Bacon Mac & Cheese

$21.75

A Pizza of the Month that was so good we had to add it to our regular menu! Mac & cheese on a pizza topped with savory bacon - yum!

Thee Spicy Pie

$21.75

Our signature pizza! THEE Spicy Pie is only for people who can take the heat: sausage, ghost pepper cheese, fresh jalapeños, banana peppers, and our spicy sauce make for the perfect spicy pizza pie!

The Carnivore

$24.25

This pizza is loaded with all of the meats! Pepperoni, sausage, Canadian bacon, bacon, and beef are piled high on this pizza. Making it the dream of meat lovers everywhere.

Margherita

$21.75

Our Margherita Pizza was a favorite pizza of the month among our customers. Fresh mozzarella, basil, and diced tomatoes are the perfect combination for that fresh taste everyone craves.

Spicy Hawaiian

$21.75

Canadian bacon, pineapple, bacon, and fresh jalapeños over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of our hand tossed crust.

Taco Pie

$23.25

If you’re craving something Taco, then order right now! Your Taco Pizza comes with a taco meat, crushed tortilla chips, shredded colby cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, and our signature Red Grinder Sauce. Don’t let this one slip on by. Choice of taco meat or shredded chicken.

Supreme

$21.75

Want a pizza that has it all? Your Supreme Pizza from Spicy Pie comes loaded with the best ingredients of pepperoni, Canadian bacon, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and black olives. You can also have it all, and have it delivered to your home.

Not-So-Skinny Vinny

$21.75

This pizza has the best, but not loaded with everything. The Not-So-Skinny Vinny has our best pepperoni, sausage, and fresh mozzarella balls. It’s simple, straight-forward and will definitely fulfill your pizza-loving-taste buds.

Buffalo Chicken

$21.75

Our Buffalo Chicken Pizza comes with shredded chicken and buffalo sauce. Sure to satisfy, and ultimately made with the best ingredients we offer.

BBQ Chicken

$21.75

Shredded chicken, bacon, pineapple, onions, and BBQ Sauce over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of our hand tossed crust.

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$23.25

Bacon is as American as baseball and apple pie. So why not add it to your Spicy Pie pizza as well? Our Chicken Bacon Ranch comes with shredded chicken, crispy bacon, and creamy ranch. It’s perfect for the bacon lover, or any pizza lover.

Vegetarian

$21.75

For those who want something lighter, we have options. Try our Vegetarian Pizza that comes with onions, green peppers, black olives, and mushrooms. You’ll love it. Not only will you enjoy the healthy nature of this pizza treat, but we know you’ll come back for more.

The Smorgasbord Pie

$22.00

Can't make a decision? Let us decide for you! This pie has 6 delicious slices to give you a little taste of everything: Buffalo Chicken, BBQ Chicken, Spicy Hawaiian, THEE Spicy Pie, Margherita, and a slice of the Pizza of the Month!

Reuben

$21.75

A Pizza of the Month our customers love so much that we decided to make it a regular menu item! Comes with Corned beef, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island Dressing.

Slices

Build Your Own

$4.99

Starts with our hand tossed crust, original or Spicy sauce, and mozzarella cheese. Then you choose what toppings to add! Starts at $3.99, additional toppings $0.40 each.

Pizza of the Month

$4.85

Our September Pizza of the Month is the Sweet & Sassy Sausage! Sausage, bacon, green peppers, onions, pineapple, ghost pepper cheese, and mango habanero sauce.

The PBR (Pickles, Bacon, Ranch)

$4.65

A BEST SELLER has been added to the menu! Pickle, bacon, ranch, cream cheese, and dill seasoning.

Thee Spicy Pie

$4.65

Our signature pizza! THEE Spicy Pie is only for people who can take the heat: sausage, ghost pepper cheese, fresh jalapeños, banana peppers, and our spicy sauce make for the perfect spicy pizza pie!

The Carnivore

$4.85

This pizza is loaded with all of the meats! Pepperoni, sausage, Canadian bacon, bacon, and beef are piled high on this pizza. Making it the dream of meat lovers everywhere.

Margherita

$4.65

Our Margherita Pizza was a favorite pizza of the month among our customers. Fresh mozzarella, basil, and diced tomatoes are the perfect combination for that fresh taste everyone craves.

Spicy Hawaiian

$4.65

Canadian bacon, pineapple, bacon, and fresh jalapeños over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of our hand tossed crust.

Taco Slice

$4.85

If you’re craving something Taco, then order right now! Your Taco Pizza comes with a taco meat, crushed tortilla chips, shredded colby cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, and our signature Red Grinder Sauce. Don’t let this one slip on by.

Supreme

$4.65

Want a pizza that has it all? Your Supreme Pizza from Spicy Pie comes loaded with the best ingredients of pepperoni, Canadian bacon, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and black olives. You can also have it all, and have it delivered to your home.

Not-So-Skinny Vinny

$4.65

This pizza has the best, but not loaded with everything. The Not-So-Skinny Vinny has our best pepperoni, sausage, and fresh mozzarella balls. It’s simple, straight-forward and will definitely fulfill your pizza-loving-taste buds.

Buffalo Chicken

$4.65

Our Buffalo Chicken Pizza comes with shredded chicken and buffalo sauce. Sure to satisfy, and ultimately made with the best ingredients we offer.

BBQ Chicken

$4.65

Shredded chicken, bacon, pineapple, onions, and BBQ Sauce over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of our hand tossed crust.

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$4.85

Bacon is as American as baseball and apple pie. So why not add it to your Spicy Pie pizza as well? Our Chicken Bacon Ranch comes with shredded chicken, crispy bacon, and creamy ranch. It’s perfect for the bacon lover, or any pizza lover.

Vegetarian

$4.65

For those who want something lighter, we have options. Try our Vegetarian Pizza that comes with onions, green peppers, black olives, and mushrooms. You’ll love it. Not only will you enjoy the healthy nature of this pizza treat, but we know you’ll come back for more.

Reuben

$4.65

A Pizza of the Month our customers love so much that we decided to make it a regular menu item! Comes with Corned beef, sauerkraut, and Thousand Island Dressing.

9" Gluten Friendly

9" Gluten Friendly Crust

$8.00

A 9" gluten free crust that starts with your choice of original or spicy sauce and Mozzarella cheese. (Please note: Our gluten free crust is cooked in the same oven as our gluten products, so it may come in contact with gluten. Please use your own discretion with your gluten allergy when consuming this crust.)

GF Pizza of the Month

$10.50

Our September Pizza of the Month is the Sweet & Sassy Sausage! Sausage, bacon, green peppers, onions, pineapple, ghost pepper cheese, and mango habanero sauce.

GF BBQ Chicken

$10.50

Shredded chicken, bacon, pineapple, onions, and BBQ Sauce over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of a 9" gluten friendly crust.

GF Buffalo Chicken

$10.50

Shredded chicken and Frank's Buffalo sauce over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of a 9" gluten friendly crust.

GF Carnivore

$10.50

All of the meats: Hormel pepperoni, Canadian bacon, sausage, beef, and bacon over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of a 9" gluten friendly crust.

GF Pepperoni

$8.00

Hormel pepperoni over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of a 9" gluten friendly crust.

GF Sausage

$8.00

Sausage over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of a 9" gluten friendly crust.

GF Cheese

$8.00

Shredded mozzarella with choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of a 9" gluten friendly crust.

GF Chicken Bacon Ranch

$10.50

Shredded chicken, bacon, and ranch over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce over top a 9" gluten friendly crust.

GF Margherita

$10.50

A 9" gluten free crust that starts with your choice of original or spicy sauce and mozzarella cheese. Than topped with Fresh Tomato, Fresh Mozzerella Cheese, and Fresh Basil.

GF Not-So-Skinny Vinny

$10.50

Fresh mozzarella cheese, Hormel pepperoni, and sausage over even more mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of our hand tossed crust.

GF Spicy Hawaiian

$10.50

Canadian bacon, pineapple, bacon, and fresh jalapeños over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of a 9" gluten friendly crust.

GF Supreme

$10.50

Hormel pepperoni, Canadian bacon, sausage, green peppers, onions, black olives, and mushrooms over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of a 9" gluten friendly crust.

GF Taco

$10.50

Taco meat or shredded chicken, Colby cheese, red grinder sauce, lettuce, crushed tortilla chips, and tomatoes over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of a 9" gluten friendly crust.

GF Thee Spicy Pie

$10.50

A 9" gluten free crust that starts with your choice of original or spicy sauce and mozzarella cheese. Then topped with Sausage, Banana Peppers, Fresh Jalapeño, and Ghost Pepper Cheese.

GF Vegetarian

$10.50

Tomatoes, onions, green peppers, black olives and mushrooms over mozzarella cheese and your choice of original or Spicy sauce all on top of a 9" gluten friendly crust.

Flatbreads

Build Your Own

$10.00

BYO Flatbread is served with Mozzerella Cheese.

Buffalo Chicken

$10.00

Shredded chicken, Frank's Buffalo sauce, and mozzarella cheese on top of a crisp flatbread.

BBQ Chicken

$10.00

Shredded chicken, onions, BBQ sauce, bacon, and mozzarella cheese on top of a crisp flatbread.

Margherita Flatbread

$10.00

Fresh tomatoes, basil leaves, and fresh mozzarella balls on top of a crisp flatbread.

PBR Flatbread

$10.00

A BEST SELLER has been added to the menu! Pickle, bacon, ranch, cream cheese, and dill seasoning.

Grinders

What’s a grinder? It’s essentially a submarine sandwich that consists of a long roll of bread split into two pieces and filled with a variety of meats, cheeses, vegetables, seasonings, and pizza sauces.

BBQ Chicken

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Shredded chicken, BBQ sauce, Swiss-American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, and onions on top of our freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Beefy Marinara

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Beef, marinara, mozzarella cheese, and Parmesan cheese on top of our freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Buffalo Chicken

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Shredded chicken, ranch, lettuce, and Frank's Buffalo sauce on our freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Chicken Bacon Ranch

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Shredded chicken, bacon, ranch, Swiss-American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, and onions on top of our freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Build Your Own

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Start with our fresh baked bread. Then add lettuce, red and white grinders sauce, Swiss-American cheese, and your choice of turkey, ham, or salami. Available in 6" or 12". Recommended baked!

Inferno

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Hormel pepperoni, sausage, ghost pepper chese, lettuce, onions, banana peppers, fresh jalapeños, a Habanero pepper, and red and white grinder sauce on top of our freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Loaded Italian

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Hormel pepperoni, salami, ham, sausage, Swiss-American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, onions, and red and white grinder sauce on top of our freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Pizza

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Hormel Pepperoni, original pizza sauce, and mozzarella cheese on top of our freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Sausage

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Sausage, green peppers, onions, lettuce, red and white grinder sauce, mozzarella cheese, and marinara sauce over freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Spicy BLT

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Hormel pepperoni, bacon, Swiss-American cheese, Spicy pizza sauce, lettuce, tomatoes, and white grinder sauce on top of our freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Sweet Chili Chicken

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Shredded chicken, Sweet Thai Chili sauce, Swiss-American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, and onions on top of freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Taco

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Taco meat, Colby cheese, lettuce, and red and white grinder sauce on top of freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Turkey Club

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Turkey, bacon, Swiss-American cheese, lettuce, tomato, green peppers, onions, and red and white grinder sauce on top of freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Ultimate

$6.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Turkey, ham, salami, taco meat, Colby cheese, Swiss-American cheese, lettuce, and red and white grinder Sauce on top of freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Veggie

$5.85 6" / $9.80 12"

Swiss-American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, black olives, onions, mushrooms, and red and white grinder sauce on top of freshly made bread. Recommended baked!

Mexican

Nachos

$9.99

Full order of tortilla chips, melted Colby cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, onions, black olives, jalapeños, salsa, and taco meat or chicken.

Chips & Sauce

$4.10

Crisp tortilla chips served with our homemade salsa or queso dip.

Hard Shell Taco

$2.99

Taco meat or shredded chicken, lettuce, Colby cheese, tomatoes, and red grinder sauce loaded into a hard shell.

Soft Shell Taco

$2.99

Taco meat or shredded chicken, lettuce, Colby cheese, tomatoes, and red grinder sauce loaded into a soft shell.

Tostada

$2.20

Lightly fried tortilla shell covered with melted cheese and red grinder sauce.

Taco Salad

$5.35

Crushed tortilla chips, tomatoes, lettuce, red grinder sauce, taco meat, Colby cheese, black olives, onions, and topped with more crushed tortilla chips.

Queso

$2.00

A 4 oz. side of Spicy Pie's new queso.

Sides

Garlic Knots

$3.00

5 pieces of hand-knotted baked dough seasoned with garlic, Parmesan, and oregano. Served with 2 sides of marinara. Single knots available for $0.75 each.

Mac & Cheese Side

$3.99

Get a classic side of Mac & cheese!

Bread Bites

$4.20

Bite sized pieces of fried dough covered with garlic Romano seasoning. Served with a side of marinara sauce, sub marinara for queso for $1 extra.

Boneless Wings

$8.00

Our boneless wings smothered in your choice of sauce: Mango Habanero, Garlic Parmesan, BBQ, Buffalo, or Sweet Thai Chili. Celery, ranch, or bleu cheese available upon request.

Bone-In Wings

$8.00

Our bone-in wings smothered in your choice of sauce: Mango Habanero, Garlic Parmesan, BBQ, Buffalo, or Sweet Thai Chili. Celery, ranch, or bleu cheese available upon request.

Queso

$2.00

A 4 oz. side of Spicy Pie's new queso.

Side Salad

$4.00

Shredded lettuce, Colby cheese, and choice of dressing. Additional toppings $0.50 each.

Cook's Salad

$5.35

Shredded lettuce, Colby cheese, black olives, green peppers, fresh tomatoes, onions, ham, turkey, and choice of dressing.

Garden Salad

$4.35

Shredded lettuce, Colby cheese, black olives, green peppers, fresh tomatoes, onions, mushrooms, banana peppers, and choice of dressing.

Sweets

Dessert Knots

$3.00

5 pieces of hand-knotted baked dough. Take your pick of either cream cheese frosting or a cinnamon glaze. Can't decide? Get a variety! Single knots available for $0.75 each.

Peanut Butter Bars

$2.50

Peanut butter dessert bars topped with melted chocolate and butterscotch. Made in house daily!

Zeppolis

$4.20

Bite sized fried pieces of dough covered in cinnamon and sugar. Served with sweet vanilla frosting.
Pizza by the Slice

With our single slice option, you can now enjoy a slice of our Spicy Pie Pizza topped your choice of various toppings. All of our specialty pies listed below are available as single slices of pizza!

Toppings
  • Anchovies
  • Bacon
  • Beef
  • Canadian Bacon
  • Ham
  • Pepperoni
  • Salami
  • Sausage
  • Shredded Smoked Chicken
  • Taco Meat
  • Turkey
  • Mac & Cheese
  • Banana Peppers
  • Basil
  • Black Olives
  • Fresh Jalapeños
  • Fresh Tomatoes
  • Green Olives
  • Green Peppers
  • Mushrooms
  • Onions
  • Pineapple
  • Sauerkraut
  • BBQ Sauce
  • Bleu Cheese
  • Buffalo Sauce
  • Crushed Tortilla Chips
  • Fresh Mozzarella
  • Garlic Romano Seasoning
  • Ghost Pepper Cheese
  • Marinara
  • Ranch
  • Red Grinder Sauce
  • Sweet Thai Chili Sauce
  • White Grinder Sauce
Build Your Own Pizza

Build your own Spicy Pie Pizza with any of your favorite, fresh toppings!

OUR crust is YOUR canvas.

Order Now